So chop me up and separate me with your cleaver
Pack the pieces you want and leave the rest at home
Cause you remind me nothing good lasts forever
Just like our innocence or Blink or even Rome
We've always had our little cake
And now I'll eat it without you
In time things slowly fade away
Those things between me and you
If I could get back just one day
I've rehearsed all I'd say to you
We've always had our little cake
And now I'll eat it without you
She'll go away to school and she'll be rewired
Memories if what you were will always stay the same
She'll meet an art major who's rich and a writer
Mouth full of hooks and blood as I bite on the bait
We've always had our little cake
And now I'll eat it without you
In time things slowly fade away
Those things between me and you
If I could get back just one day
I've rehearsed all I'd say to you
We've always had our little cake
And now I'll eat it without you
Do you remember who we were for for all our fun
We promised things could be the same but we were wrong
This worlds a scary place for those of us barred from owning guns
I never cared at all thats why I wrote you a song
We've always had our little cake
And now I'll eat it without you
In time things slowly fade away
Those things between me and you
If I could get back just one day
I've rehearsed all I'd say to you
We've always had our little cake
And now I'll eat it without you