Sunday night you drive me home
Four days straight of you and I alone
Lights are off and no one's home
I can feel a storm coming on
When I told you that your friend was blowing up my phone
You looked at me as if I had said something wrong
You looked at me and suddenly I felt my glow
Dimmer
Than the light on the refrigerator
When you agreed with me
It came naturally
It came magically
You agreed with me
It was easy
To hold me
To kiss me
But not romantically
So tell me what do I do now
With all this brand new information that I've found
Sit and stare at myself frown
Sit and stare and try to talk myself down
Or maybe I should call up your friend
How could I begin to pretend
How could he begin to even understand
That it was nothing, alright
I just thought that it was nice
That you agreed with me
It came naturally
It came magically
You agreed with me
It was easy
To hold me
To kiss me
But not romantically
Just tragically
As I watch you walk away
For the hundredth time I say
Why not romantically
Am I cursed to be
The one that got away
For the hundredth time I say
Maybe someday
You'll agree
It came naturally
It came magically
You'll agree with me
It was easy
To hold me
To kiss me
To love me
So romantically
So romantically
So, so, so, so
Romantically
So romantically
So, so, so, so