I was there the night that Jimmy and Meaghan met
It was kinda sorta awkward but I don't think I'll ever forget
How his eyes lit up when he was next to her
Then Jimmy was like, "Hey let's hang out again" and Meaghan said "Okay"
And suddenly Meaghan had Jimmy falling harder every day
And now it all seems like a blur
But ain't it such a tragedy
That even the best strategy
Can leave a loverboy dancing on his own
All the girls worth falling for
Are the ones that leave you craving more
If only he had known
Couple weeks went by and Jimmy and Meaghan went to prom together
I'll say that limo ride was certainly one to remember
Seemed like they might've found the keys to each other
Meaghan was dancing away while Jimmy's feet were cold
But she loosened him up and saw in him a man so kind and bold
But she never saw a lover
And ain't it such a tragedy
That even the best strategy
Can leave a loverboy dancing on his own
All the girls worth falling for
Are the ones that leave you craving more
If only he had known
He's had his poor heart broken before
He's holding out and hoping she won't leave him at the door
And she don't wanna hurt him and watch him sink
He can bring her to the water but he can't make her drink
And I guess that's true for all the loverboys too
And I guess that's true for all the loverboys too
And ain't it such a tragedy
That even the best strategy
Can leave a loverboy dancing on his own
All the girls worth falling for
Are the ones that leave you craving more
If only he had known
If only she had known
If only we had known