That was the night that you ripped my heart out of my chest
October nights, thought that they'd never pass, came and went
You said you'd love me till both of us wound up dead
Now I know you were never worth a word that you said
That was the night that you threw my heart right on the ground
Cracks in the bricks gave me company on the ride home
For the first time this year, I can see my breath in front of my face
For the first time this year, I feel nothing but alone
That was the night that you took me and swallowed me whole
Took all you could from me, never gave back what you stole
If I could work up the nerve to lose what I worked for all year
I'd risk all I have in the search of feeling whole
Give back what you stole