I've never seen you before, I've never wanted to know more
Caroline you crazy feather, You craze me like the weather
And all the eyes that look at you, Silently whispering your name
We felt the air get colder, But it seems our hearts got warmer
Pasadena you're making me blush, Just feeling all the blood rush
To our cheeks is it the soft snow, Or emotions we don't even know?
Splashing water all together, Caroline's drowning in the hot sun
Pasadena sits in the shade, And I stand in the water thinking
Where we are is oh-so pleasant, Nothing could ever replace this
Caroline and Pasadena, Recently just fought each other
About something I don't know, Has it just been boiling all along?
"You and I should've been together"
"You and I should've kissed when we had the chance"
We don't ever talk anymore, Patching up things didn't really work
Caroline's car crashed the other day, Pasadena packed up and flew away
And I'm still in the spot I was, When we were hanging out together
Caroline and Pasadena, Both girls of which I really loved
Both who I'll never confess, Both who have moved on from this mess
The love triangle's corners cut off, Emotions rushed out as I picked up the phone
My voice cracked when I heard hers, I wanted to tell her "I'm yours"
The best of me caught up fast though, And only a few words got out
I don't remember who hung up first, But I know we'd never talk after that day
On Caroline's birthday, I went to talk to her grave
Maybe some resolution finally came, By repeating the words I'd always say
And all the time I'd think
And all the time I'd think
And all the time I'd think
I'd think about you all the time